Awards and how to survive them

It’s a lot of fun winning awards. It’s gratifying, it’s validating, it just downright makes you feel good. Nothing wrong with that. And people always say that it’s an honor just to be nominated (usually those are the people who didn’t win). I don’t know exactly how many awards I’ve won (no, I don’t count them every day and I don’t EVER dust them!) but here’s the important thing- however many times I’ve won award competitions, there are probably ten times as many award competitions that I haven’t won. If you venture into the “awards game,” you’d better get used to losing a LOT. Since we’re kind of in the middle of Western Awards Season (Will Rogers Medallion, IWMA, AWA), I thought I might share some perspective on all that.
Here’s a dirty little secret: not all awards are created equal. Some are very meaningful and prestigious while others are basically available to anyone with the money to enter the competition. The awards are very similar to those ribbons that 8 year olds on soccer teams get for “competing.” They don’t mean the same thing. If your goal is to pad your resume and feed your ego, I would suggest that you’re in it for all the wrong reasons. If you’re winning almost every time, either you’re a genius or you’re entering the wrong award competitions.
When you submit a work for an award and see that you are a finalist in a category, the first thing you should do is look at the other people in your category. I’ve learned to do that. If I look at the competition and my reaction is “WHOAH, I don’t have a prayer, these guys are great!”, I know I’ve come to the right place. If you don’t win, you can honestly hold your head up and say what an honor it was to be mentioned in the same sentence as those other folks. If you do win, you know you really have done something of which you can be proud.
As writers, performers, artists and the like, our number one job is to create the best possible work that we are capable of- a quality work that has artistic value. Our number two job is to create something that people connect with, that makes them think and feel. The nicest award I ever got was when someone came up to me after a performance and said, “I loved your songs. I felt like you were writing about my life.” That is what I consider a worthwhile accomplishment.